Holistic Dog Foods or Regular Pet Brands?
by Jade's Bark on Nov.04, 2007, under Animals, Dog Products
Many pet owners take the convenient route, and while shopping for groceries pick up any range of pet food brands from the pet food isle of their local grocery store. Brands that are well known and well heard of, such as Purina®, Alpo® Authority®etc…
Is there anything wrong with that? Well, I am by no standards an expert on pet foods, nor am I an expert on doggy nutrition. So what gives me the right to write anything on the subject of pet foods? Simple… I am a dog owner of dogs that eat dog food. Wait! I am more than that… I am the owner of two dogs with THE MOST irritable and sensitive intestines out there! When my family adopted them, they had tummies filled with every worm and parasite imaginable, and were on their death beds from Parvovirus. Needless to say, my dogs thankfully survived, but were left with extremely sensitive intestines, and I have cleaned up countless mishaps of upchucks and runny bum accidents from the floors of my house. (see my review on Dyson, and Bisselle link to be added)
I have asked the question to different vets about what brand of pet food I should feed my dogs, and they have mentioned various brands. Unfortunately, I am skeptical as to whether these vet offices are supported financially by some of the pet brands, and have given up hope on a verifiable answer from any of them. However, I was tipped off by one vet in particular after seeking her advice for my dogs’ growing weight problems, that Purina® and a lot of other regular store brand doggy foods are filled with a lot of empty calories.
Armed with this info, I had to make a choice. I then decided that Eukanuba® and Iams® were more expensive than Purina® and therefore must be more nutritious. Nothing but the best for my doggies! These seemed to work well, although my dogs seemed tired of the same dog food brands and did not seem to like them very much. I then tried Nature’s Balance and so many other various higher priced dog foods found in your regular pet store shelves. They seemed to like Iams and Eukanuba the best, and these are the dog foods we settled on for years.
This past year, there were many dog food recalls due to the wheat gluten issue etc, and during the last recall scare, many dogs became sick from the wheat gluten. There were many rumors that there were a lot more dogs and cats sick than was announced on the news and that a lot of the incidents were “hush hush”.
During these scary times, my dogs mysteriously began vomiting a lot, and having bloody diarrhea. Eukanuba/Iams Company put out a statement that they were not involved in the recalls, and that their dog foods were safe. 1 It is a strange coincidence that my dogs were ill considering they had been eating only Eukanuba® and Iams® dog food brands.
I have asked a few dog owners who feed their dogs Eukanuba® or Iams if their dogs were sick as well, but I have not heard of others sick from these brands, although this does not mean there are none. So what made my dogs sick? It is unknown.
My theories which can not be prove are;
- Only a small number of bags from Eukanuba and Iams were affected, and we won the unlucky lottery**,
- The dog food was slightly tainted, and most dogs were able to pass it off as no more than a slight tummy upset,while my dogs with their most sensitive damaged tummies could not handle the contamination.**, or;
- Yes, it could be some extraneous item in the backyard, but what that could be is a mystery.
or
- Once again these are only theories.
Whatever the cause of my dogs’ illnesses, made their tummies even worse than they already were. They were no longer able to handle any dog food it seemed. We tried brand after brand giving their tummies rest in between by cooking rice soup and meat, even taking the chance to go back to Eukanuba and Iams after the dog food crisis was over. The only thing the dogs were able to tolerate was the rice soup and meat that I was cooking for them. They could not even tolerate table scraps that shouldn’t have made them sick in any way. The doggies were having such terrible diarrhea and vomiting episodes.
We looked into the various small company Holistic dog foods that were popping up everywhere taking advantage of the recall and dog food scare time periods. We listened to their claims that regular store bought dog food brands used whatever leftovers that FDA did not allow sold as human goods. We listened to their claims that the dog foods contained corn and other items that were very hard to digest. We also listened to their claims that their brands although much more expensive, were better, contained better ingredients, and lacked all the bad ingredients that the regular store brands contained. I was not convinced that these were not just false accusations, and false claims, but tired of having to cook everyday for my dogs, and worried that they were not getting enough nutrition that dog foods could give them, I ordered a new holistic dog brand. Life’s Abundance Premium Health Food for Puppies & Adult Dogs from www.trilogyonline.com.
I can not say for sure that holistic dog foods have better ingredients like they claim, or that their statements are completely accurate, or even that the regular brand dog foods caused my dogs’ further tummy problems. However, my dogs have been able to digest Life’s Abundance just fine, but can not tolerate the majority of the famous store brands. The fact that other dog food brands make our dogs sick and this brand and a few other holistic brands do not, makes me believe many store brands do in fact have a lot of non digestible contents and that holistic dog brands are really better. I would highly recommend dog owners to look into changing their brands to holistic ones. Sure they may carry a higher price, but our dog’s health is every bit worth it. Please look into any brand you are going to buy carefully before deciding that they are a legit holistic dog food company, and that their claims are true and accurate.
—Jade
**this blog statement is not endorsed by any pet food brand, nor are the accusations made to various named pet brands proof of anything, these are simply the author’s personal opinions or observations. The theories of this author can not be considered slander, as it is clearly stated that all of the above happenings are simply theories and opinions not proven or disproven by any facts.
1
http://us.eukanuba.com/eukanuba/global/EukanubaMediaStmt.htm
January 24th, 2010 on 8:16 PM
Shame on you for creating another terrific post! Awesome stuff, keep up the good work. I see a lot of potential! make money on line
February 17th, 2010 on 8:07 AM
Welcome First time bounded here on your site, founde on ASK. South African Airways
February 19th, 2010 on 7:48 PM
Very good blog post I love your site keep up the great posts Wilmer Redford
March 5th, 2010 on 1:32 AM
Interesting , how would I apply this? Short sale in San Diego
March 7th, 2010 on 4:30 PM
You know, I have to tell you, I really relish this website and the great insight. I find it to be energizing and quite enlightening. I wish there were more blogs like it. Anyway, I finally decided to write a comment on Holistic Dog Foods or Regular Pet Brands? | The Barking Lot – I just wanted to say that you did a good job on this. Cheers dude! Sadie Nooman
April 23rd, 2010 on 12:06 AM
The desire of knowledge, like the thirst for riches, increases ever with the acquisition of it. allan